The introduction of cell phone bans in schools is one of the current education policy debates in Germany, which is met with both approval and fierce rejection. Critics of such a ban argue that it not only harms pupils, but also disregards a broader social responsibility. Not only does not allowing schools to include cell phones in lessons mean a denial of digital reality, it also means that tech companies are increasingly exerting uncontrolled influence over students. Instead of teaching them how to use digital technologies confidently and responsibly, they are being forced into a passive role in which they become mere objects of commercial platforms.

A key problem with the cell phone ban is the fact that it weakens the media skills of both pupils and teachers. In an increasingly digitalized world, it is essential that young people learn to navigate digital spaces safely and responsibly. Instead of burying our heads in the sand and pretending that cell phone addiction, cyberbullying and social isolation have no real impact, the school system should take targeted measures to train students and teachers in the use of digital media. Such media literacy training would not only help pupils to arm themselves against the dangers of the internet, such as cyberbullying, but also to make sensible use of the potential of technology.

The comparison to the "bird's-eye policy" is by no means exaggerated. If state parliaments in Germany continue to focus on "solving" the cell phone problem with bans, they are failing to provide pupils with the tools they need to act independently and safely in the digital world. It's not just a question of technical access, but also the responsibility that comes with this access. While platforms such as Facebook, Instagram and TikTok continue to grow in popularity and shape young people's digital spaces, schools remain inactive. Refusing to teach young people how to use these platforms is a missed opportunity to constructively tackle the emerging challenges.

Teaching students how to confidently defend themselves against cyberbullying and how to use social networks responsibly will not only improve their use of technology, but also boost their self-confidence and independence. They learn how to navigate between the real and digital worlds without falling into the traps of addiction, isolation or bullying.

Overall, it is clear that banning cell phones is not the solution to the complex problems of the digital world. Rather, it is an invitation to ignorance that harms both students and society as a whole. Instead of burying its head in the sand, the education system should see the challenges of the digital transformation as an opportunity to actively integrate media skills into the curriculum and thus prepare young people for the digital future. This is the only way to prevent them from becoming passengers on the journey through the digital world instead of active and self-confident co-creators.

Thoughts from Niko Fostiropoulos, Managing Director of the education company alfatraining.

Formulated with AI support. 25.03.2025